Difference between revisions of "IEDB Inclusion Criteria"
(→Exclusion: Adoptive Transfer)
|Line 312:||Line 312:|
D) Infectious diseases not listed above under sections ([[#Curation Prioritization]]) A) and B)
D) Infectious diseases not listed above under sections ([[#Curation Prioritization]]) A) and B)
==Minimal Data Requirements==
==Minimal Data Requirements==
Revision as of 23:57, 9 May 2013
- 1 Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria
- 1.1 Relevant Experimental Data
- 1.2 Epitopes Relevant to IEDB
- 1.3 Minimal Data Requirements
All articles and epitopes must meet inclusion criteria in order to be included in the database.
Relevant Experimental Data
The reference must report original and experimental epitope-related data.
- Computer derived predictions without functional experimental data will not be included in the database.
- Sequence analysis of defined epitopes will not be included in the database unless novel information is provided (e.g., identification of anchor residues).
- Reviews and meta analysis will not be included in the database.
- Data not shown is not curated.
- Personal communication is not sufficient for curation.
- When encountering data from previous publications which are included in figures or tables, the curator should determine if the previous record was curated and if it was not, the PMID should be sent to the Document Specialist to be included in the database.
Scope and Exclusions
The experimental data must fall within the scope of the database.
Relevant data includes:
- MHC binding data
- Epitope elution from MHC (Naturally processed MHC ligands)
- T cell responses to an epitope (including NK T cells)
- B cell/antibody responses to an epitope
Certain categories of experimental data will be specifically excluded from the database.
Exclusion: NK Epitopes
Epitopes that are recognized by Natural Killer cells (non-T cell) will be excluded from the database. Please note: NK T cell epitopes/ligands will be included (as noted in section (#Scope and Exclusions).
Exclusion: Non-Immunological Interpretation of "Epitope"
Experimental data describing "epitopes" in non-immunological contexts will not be included in the database. For example, the structures that are in contact in protein-protein interactions are sometimes referred to as an epitope. This interpretation of "epitope" will not be included in the database.
Exclusion: Epitope Tags
References discussing epitope tags utilized as a technical tool for immunoprecipitation, purification, and similar experiments will be excluded from the database.
References discussing superantigens in the context of peptide-MHC-super antigen complexes will be excluded from the database. However, B cell/antibody responses to superantigens (especially Staphylococcus enterotoxin B (SEB), a NIAID Category B priority pathogen) will be curated.
Important Note: In the event superantigen is used as part of an assay to stabilize the interaction of an epitope with MHC, the epitope studied is curatable and should be captured.
Exclusion: TCR Antagonism
Data related to TCR antagonism will not be curated. Author stated TCR antagonism will not be curated, however, TCR competition not specifically labeled as TCR antagonism by the authors will be curated. TCR antagonism used in an MHC binding inhibition assay will be captured as an MHC binding assay.
Exclusion: Antigen Processing
Data concerning the processing of antigens generated in order to study the effects of variables on processing rather than on the study of an epitope (i.e. the epitope is irrelevant) are not to be included in the database unless the identification of a novel epitope is demonstrated.
Epitopes Relevant to IEDB
|Epitope Class||Uncuratable||Epitopic Region (# residues)||Epitope|
|B-cell||> 5 kDa or 50 amino acids||12 - 50||1 ≤ x ≤ 11|
|Class I||> 5 kDa or 50 amino acids||12 - 50||7 ≤ x ≤ 11|
|Class II||> 5 kDa or 50 amino acids||16 - 50||7 ≤ x ≤ 15|
The database will only include epitopes of less than 50 residues in either a linear or conformational sequence.
Important Exception: Epitopes greater than 50 residues will be curated for certain pathogens including Botulinum toxin and anthrax epitopes.
A region or fragment of >50aa from B. anthracis and C. botulinum will be curated as an epitopic region in the following cases:
For non-peptidic epitopes, the mass restriction is to be less than 5000 Daltons to be included in the database.
- For Antibody/B Cell and Class I epitopes if the size is 1100 Dalton or less, the epitope should be designated as an Exact Epitope.
- For linear Class II epitopes, select Exact Epitope if the sequence is 1500 Dalton or less in length.
To broaden the spectrum of information in the database, we previously excluded the repeated curation of epitopes once 10 key references have been included in the database. The original articles describing the epitope, MHC restriction data, antibody responses, and articles containing novel information regarding the epitope were included in the approximately 10 references.
The concept of well-characterized/blacklisted has been eliminated. Going forward, we will avoid curating papers that focus on exploring strategies to enhance well characterized epitope's immunogenicity. These papers use well-characterized peptides to evaluate variables such as alternative immunogen constructs (MAPS/vectors) or adjuvants.
All references should be evaluated for novelty such as providing a new assay type, host, MHC restriction, or outcome for the given epitope.
- When well-characterized epitopes are studied in a novel host in terms of the MHC, TCR, antibody, or otherwise, the reference will be included in the database.
- When well-characterized epitopes are used as controls they will not be curated. However, when the well-characterized epitope is used as a reference for a novel epitope from the same source protein, the well-characterized epitope will also be captured.
- When a reference describes a well-characterized epitope in addition to other curatable epitopes, all of the epitopes from the reference will be captured.
- At the curators/EC discretion, papers describing new/additional original data relating to these epitopes can and will be curated. For example, if the paper make a novel discovery about the epitope.
- all human data should be captured
- always ask before deciding to not curate any reference
References describing only epitopes derived from HIV/SIV will not be included in the database. However, when a manuscript describes epitopes from other relevant sources as well as HIV/SIV, all of the epitopes in the manuscript will be captured.
Epitope curation should be conducted in the following priority order:
A) NIAID Category A, B, and C priority pathogens and toxins:
The complete list of NIAID Category A, B, and C priority pathogens and toxins can be found at the following URL: http://www2.niaid.nih.gov/biodefense/bandc_priority.htm.
NIAID – Category A
Bacillus anthracis (anthrax)
Variola major (smallpox) and other pox viruses
Francisella tularensis (tularemia)
Viral hemorrhagic fevers
LCM, Junin virus, Machupo virus, Guanarito virus
Rift Valley Fever
NIAID – Category B
Coxiella burnetii (Q fever)
Brucella species (brucellosis)
Burkholderia mallei (glanders)
Ricin toxin (from Ricinus communis)
Epsilon toxin of Clostridium perfringens
Staphylococcus enterotoxin B
Typhus fever (Rickettsia prowazekii)
Food and Waterborne Pathogens
Viruses (Caliciviruses, Hepatitis A)
Additional viral encephalitides
West Nile Virus
Japanese Encephalitis Virus
Kyasanur Forest Virus
NIAID – Category C
Tickborne hemorrhagic fever viruses
Crimean-Congo Hemorrhagic fever virus
Tickborne encephalitis viruses
Multi-drug resistant TB
Severe acute respiratory syndrome-associated coronavirus (SARS-CoV)
B) Emerging and Re-emerging pathogens:
Pathogens newly recognized in the past two decades
Australian bat lyssavirus
Hendra or equine morbilli virus
Human herpesvirus 8
Human herpesvirus 6
Coronaviruses/Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS)
Streptococcus, group A
- Coccidioides immitis
C) Transplant rejection antigens and other alloantigens, Allergens, and Self antigens involved in autoimmunity
D) Infectious diseases not listed above under sections (#Curation Prioritization) A) and B)
Minimal Data Requirements
The reference must contain information for all required fields for at least one epitope in order to be included in the database. There are five major categories containing twenty-six fields. One set of data from each category must be available. These fields are highlighted in yellow in the data dictionary available in the Curation Network folder: (\\Curation\Docs\DataDictionary\). The required fields are listed in Table 3
|#||Section Classification||Field Name||Comments|
|1||a||Reference -Journal Article||PubMed ID||At least one set of fields from Category # 1 (1a, 1b or 1c) has to be filled out.|
|b||i||Reference - Submission||Author(s)|
|ii||Reference - Submission||Affiliation(s)|
|c||Reference - Patents||Paten Publication Number|
|2||a||Epitope Structure||Linear Sequences||At least one of the three fields from Category # 2 (2a,2b or 2c) has to be filled out.|
|b||Epitope Structure||SMILES Structure|
|c||Epitope Structure||Conformational Sequence|
|3||a||Epitope Structure||Epitopic Region / Domain||Mandatory field. This Boolean field indicates whether the epitope that is captured is a minimal epitope or contained within a region / domain.|
|4||a||Epitope Source||Epitope Source Nature||At least one of the seven fields from Category # 4 (4a, 4b, 4c, 4d, 4e, 4f or 4g) has to be filled out. If the value of natural Antigen, which is a Boolean field, is ’no’, all other Epitope-Source fields are ignored.|
|b||Epitope Source||Source Species|
|c||Epitope Source||Gene Name|
|d||Epitope Source||Protein Name|
|e||Epitope Source||GenBank ID|
|f||Epitope Source||Swiss Prot ID|
|g||Epitope Source||PDB ID|
|5||a||i||MHC Binding||MHC Allele||At least one set of fields from Category # 5 (5a, 5b, 5c, 5d) has to be filled out. All the fields in a subsection has to be filled out if that subsection is selected. For example, if 5a is chosen, all three fields (5a-i,ii,iii) have to be filled out. The following fields - Assay Type, and Qualitative Measurement, can be entered as "Unknown" if the data is unavailable. It’s anticipated that most the data imports from other existing databases might not have the assay related fields|
|ii||MHC Binding||Assay Type|
|iii||MHC Binding||Qualitative Measurement|
|b||i||MHC Ligand Elution||MHC Allele|
|ii||MHC Ligand Elution||Assay Type|
|iii||MHC Ligand Elution||Qualitative Measurement|
|c||i||T Cell Response - Assay||MHC Allele|
|ii||T Cell Response - Assay||Assay Type|
|iii||T Cell Response - Assay||Qualitative Measurement|
|d||i||B Cell Response - Assay||Assay Type|
|ii||B Cell Response - Assay||Qualitative Measurement|
Epitope Structure Availability
In the event the exact epitope structure is not given in the reference, follow these guidelines:
I) Contact the corresponding author(s) using the template contact letter provided in the Curation Folder based upon information given in the manuscript. In the internal Curation Tracking System (CTS):
- A) Fill out F2: Status should be "Waiting for author’s response". Enter author’s e-mail address and date of e-mail in Comments section of F2 form.
- B) Once author provides structure(s): Complete the curation of the article, including "Provided by author" in the Data Location Field in Epitope Structure.
- C) Update F2, adding comments to include by whom and when the information was sent.
II) If an e-mail address is not provided in the article, a reference cited by the manuscript regarding the epitope structure may be used for sequence information. The [Epitope Structure] Data Location Field should state where the information was found as cited reference or author communication.
The following format should be used anytime literature is cited in the IEDB: Sette et al. (2007). Nature 48: 1141-7. [PMID:12345678]
When citing epitope location, “Reference cited” should be used in location field and citation information should be placed in comments. Provide the PMID whenever it can be easily obtained.
III) If doubts persist regarding the epitope structure, the data cannot be included in the database. If the author does not respond within two weeks, the reference will be deemed uncuratable. Curation status in Form F2 should be selected as <Uncuratable: Reference Scan> with comments including the reason(s) why the epitope/reference was deemed uncuratable.
Important Note: Cited References The same guidelines are to be applied when researching context information such as the generation of T cell clones or monoclonal antibodies. When researching clone production and mAb generation, only go to references cited by the paper that you are curating. If those references do not provide the needed information, do not continue to search further. Add an immunization comment stating that the details were not provided and clarify this point to the reviewer on the cover sheet, letting the reviewer know that you did look at the references, but still could not find the needed information.